For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared governance from pointless and unlikely to possible and intriguing, "Shared Governance in Higher Education, Volume 1" will trigger meaningful conversations by offering valuable new perspectives. Experienced governance members, the contributors provide practical insights for everyone involved in academic governance and illuminate the subtle ...Noelle Chaddock. CHAPTER FOUR “Nailing Descartes to the Wall” by Propagandhi Lauren Corman and Sarat Colling. PART III. RESISTANCE. CHAPTER FIVE “Fight the Power” by Public Enemy David Stovall. CHAPTER SIX “Hero of War” by Rise Against Scott Robertson. PART IV. REBELLION. CHAPTER SEVEN “Hip Hop is Dead” …Dr. Noelle Chaddock. Jun 14, 2020; 3 min read; Black Transracial Adoption and Genealogical Silence. Updated: Dec 7, 2021. It is a reoccurring dream really. No, it is ...Noelle Chaddock PhD. Associate Dean of Academic Affairs for Diversity and Inclusion at Rhodes College "Engaging, genuine and transparently inspiring! Carlos Malave is CJ Motivation-with a truly relatable flair! His, "Translating Your Success" book and workshop is a great addition to any conference seeking to deliver practical tools to increase ...Antagonizing White Feminism Noelle Chaddock 2019-12-15 Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality's Critique of Women's Studies and the Academy pushes back against the exclusive scholarship and discourse coming out of women-centered spaces and projects, which throw up barriers by narrowly defining who can participate. Vehement ...1 1 National Day of Silence April 20, 2012 is the National Day of Silence. The Day of Silence is a student-led national event that brings attention to anti-LGBTQI name-NTAHQ was established in November 2005 to meet the needs of professionals involved with healthcare quality. Our membership benefits include monthly educational meetings with CEs, networking opportunities, sharing best practices, and leadership opportunities. We serve a variety of healthcare professionals, including, but not limited to ...Bulletin Online Newsletter. Faculty/Staff Detail. Noelle Chaddock, Multicultural Life and Diversity Office, gave a talk at the SUNY Voices System Wide Conference titled …Steven Parker, assistant dean of the Office of Intercultural Education, meets with Vice President of Equity and Inclusion Noelle Chaddock in the OIE. "I have enjoyed my time at Bates so far. The students are lively, and eager to create inclusive change. The faculty and staff have been helpful as well.Noelle Chaddock, VP for Equity & Inclusion, Bates College Celina Chatman Nelson, Assoc. Dean for Academic Diversity & Inclusion, Columbia University Arselyne Cherry, Williams College Class of 2021 Sara Dubow, Associate Dean of the Faculty; Professor of History, Williams CollegeExposure ready, set, go! Orientation Week for the Class of 2023 sets the year in motion Published 2019-09-13 16:17:14 UTC Story by Bates College From Opening Day on Aug. 26 to Opening Convocation on Sept. 3, the 501 members of the Class of 2023 had nine days to settle in, meet new friends, start sports and activities, get a taste of Bates academics, and explore Lewiston and Maine.Noelle Chaddock is vice president of equity and inclusion at Bates College. Beth Hinderliter is assistant professor of art history and director of the Duke Hall Gallery of Fine Art at James Madison University.For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared governance from pointless and unlikely to possible and intriguing, "Shared Governance in Higher Education, Volume 1" will trigger meaningful conversations by offering valuable new perspectives. Experienced governance members, the contributors provide practical insights for everyone involved in academic governance and illuminate the subtle ...*a note: I am aware of the antagonism of and in the word bastard. I am using it intentionally. In my writing it is part reclamation and part injured angry abandoned child. I am sorry if the use of the word bastard keeps you from reading the work. Please know I use it a lot in this article. As I watch Texas intentionally skirt, derail, suppress and ultimately avoid if not abort the Public ...... Chaddock}, title = {Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality?s Critique of Women?s Studies and the Academy} }. Hinderliter, Beth & Chaddock, Noelle (eds.) ...For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared governance from pointless and unlikely to possible and intriguing, "Shared Governance in Higher Education, Volume 1" will trigger meaningful conversations by offering valuable new perspectives. Experienced governance members, the contributors provide practical insights for everyone involved in academic governance and illuminate the subtle ...Noelle Chaddock, Vice President for Equity and Inclusion Jon Furbush ʼ05, Head Men's Basketball Coach. 3:40pm Audrey Burns ʼ17, Assistant Dean of Admission Jay Burns Pʼ17, Pʼ19, Editorial Director and Editor, Bates Magazine Johie Seltzer ʼ03, Senior Associate Dean of Admission and Director of Communications and Outreach. 4:05pm86 - 91 Beth Hinderliter and Noelle Chaddock, "A Rejection of White Feminist Cisgender Allyship: Centering Intersectionality," in Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality's Critique of Women's Studies and the Academy, Edited by Noelle Chaddock and Beth Hinderliter (Lanham, MD: Lexington Books 2019), 137-45.Book Review: Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality’s Critique of Women’s Studies and the Academy edited by Noelle Chaddock and Beth Hinderliter. Elizabeth Venell. Gender & Society 0 10.1177/08912432221106766 Download Citation.Noelle Chaddock, PhD. Associate Dean of Academic Affairs for Diversity and Inclusion at Rhodes College. Engaging, genuine and transparently inspiring! Carlos Malave is CJ Motivation-with a truly relatable flair! His, “Translating Your Success” book and workshop is a great addition to any conference seeking to deliver practical tools to ...As module A came to an end, students in Playwriting, taught by Lecturer in Theater Cliff Odle and the junior-senior Autofiction seminar, taught by Lecturer in English Jessica Anthony, presented readings of their work via Zoom on Oct. 13 and 15, respectively. The readings were open to the Bates community to celebrate student work —...Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality’s Critique of Women’s Studies and the Academy is written by Noelle Chaddock, Beth Hinderliter and published by Lexington Books. The Digital and eTextbook ISBNs for Antagonizing White Feminism are 9781498588355, 1498588352 and the print ISBNs are 9781498588362, 1498588360. Save up to 80% versus print by going digital with VitalSource ...October 22, 2020 3pm – 5pm EST. As Vice President for Equity and Inclusion, Noelle Chaddock works with colleagues to cultivate a welcoming, inclusive, equitable and …with Noelle Chaddock Paley and Sebastian Purcell. M.O.V.E. Event On April 20, Men of Value and Excellence held a presentation and luncheon with keynote speaker Arel Moodie, one of the leading voices on helping young students get to and get through college. He works with students from all backgrounds to make sure they are ready for the journey ...dialogue, led by Noelle Chaddock Paley, Director, Multicultural Life and Diversity and a panel of speakers. The Syracuse Gay & Lesbian Chorus will be performing in Brown Auditorium on the evening of Nov. 14. The LGBTQ Faculty Committee welcomes all faculty, staff, and students to attend, support and spread the word that hate will not be tolerated.For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared governance from pointless and unlikely to possible and intriguing, "Shared Governance in Higher Education, Volume 1" will trigger meaningful conversations by offering valuable new perspectives. Experienced governance members, the contributors provide practical insights for everyone involved in academic governance and illuminate the subtle ...Introduction: “Antagonizing White Feminism.” Noelle Chaddock and Beth Hinderliter 1. “White Feminism is the Only Feminism.” Noelle Chaddock 2. “Unsettling Dominant Femininities: Promissory Notes Towards an Antiracist Feminist College.” Piya Chatterjee 3. “Repo Fem.” Timothy W. Gerken 4.View the profiles of professionals named "Noelle Chaddock" on LinkedIn. There are 3 professionals named "Noelle Chaddock", who use LinkedIn to exchange …Johnson, Noelle Chaddock Paley, Ute Ritz-Deutch, and Lori Schlicht. Community Partner recipients were: Aaron Baier, Kim Mullins, and Mary Jane Uttech. Student Group recipients were Etta Sigma Gamma Health Honorary and SUNY Cortland Emergency Medical Services. Thirty-five SUNY Cortland AmeriCorps MembersView Noelle Chaddock results including current phone number, address, relatives, background check report, and property record with Whitepages. ...Jan 15, 2020 · Hope-Lynn Nash, 21, receives maximum prison sentence for a crash that killed 51-year-old Bryan Chaddock on Aug. 5. ... He lived it to the fullest every day," said Noelle Chaddock, his ex-wife and ... o A talk by Noelle Chaddock Paley, director of the College's Multicultural Life Office and a faculty member in Africana Studies. She will outline a new direction for programming in her area on ...Noelle Chaddock is a Chief Equity and Inclusion Officer at Community Education Group based in Washington, District of Columbia. Noelle received a Ph. D. degree from Binghamton University. Read More. Contact. Noelle Chaddock's Phone Number and Email. Last Update. 11/10/2022 6:45 PM. Email.Frank Chaddock is 81 years old and was born on 07/10/1942. Frank Chaddock lives in Clovis, NM; previous cities include Carrollton TX, Norwalk CA and Los Angeles CA. Frank James Chaddock, Frank J Chaddock and Frank F Chaddock are some of the alias or nicknames that Frank has used. Other family members and associates include Arthur Mayfield ...Jul 16, 2020 · Dr. Noelle Chaddock. Apr 5, 2019; 4 min; Cast Not. 41. 0. 1 like. Post not marked as liked 1. Home: Blog2. About. I am Noelle. That is the only piece of me that has ... Noelle Chaddock is vice president of equity and inclusion at Bates College. Beth Hinderliter is assistant professor of art history and director of the Duke Hall Gallery of Fine Art at James Madison University.Jan 19, 2021 · A third senior, Bates Black Student Union President Joshua Redd, formally introduced Angela Davis, and moderator Vice President for Equity and Inclusion Noelle Chaddock introduced Pickens. Doug Hubley is a writer and musician living in Portland, Maine. Hernandez, Noelle Chaddock, Jessica Perez, David Paulino and Ashley Perez. "Not only was the scenery breath taking, but they actually had the opportunity to sit in their senator's chair and mirror the process that the actual senators preform to deliver their arguments." -William HernandezNoelle Chaddock is vice president of equity and inclusion at Bates College. Beth Hinderliter is assistant professor of art history and director of the Duke Hall Gallery of Fine Art at James Madison University. Limited-Time Offer. 3 Months FREE of Audible Premium Plus. Get this deal.Noelle Chaddock is vice president of equity and inclusion at Bates College. Beth Hinderliter is assistant professor of art history and director of the Duke Hall Gallery of Fine Art at James Madison University. Limited-Time Offer. 3 Months FREE of Audible Premium Plus. Get this deal.It is a reoccurring dream really. No, it is a nightmare. Worse, it is my reality. I am away from my body. – whether awake or asleep – and I can see that I am in distress. I feel distressed. There are people all around me some black, some brown, many indigenous and we are all – disconnected – not moving at all. We are making no sound. But our lips are moving. The …I taught my daughter to dance and sing in the kitchen in the early afternoons on hot summer days. I taught my daughter to love her big, curly, mane of hair. I taught my daughter to use her privilege and Irish aesthetic toward racial equity. I taught my daughter to be a disrupter, a trailblazer, a kind and loving person who takes care of others. As we …Dec 28, 2018 · Dr. Noelle Chaddock, currently the associate provost and deputy Title IX coordinator at Rhodes College, has been appointed vice president for equity and inclusion at Bates College, effective June 1. Chaddock also previously served as chief diversity officer at the State University of New York at Cortland. Dr. Noelle Chaddock Noelle Chaddock, Vice President for Equity and Inclusion Jon Furbush ʼ05, Head Men's Basketball Coach. 3:40pm Audrey Burns ʼ17, Assistant Dean of Admission Jay Burns Pʼ17, Pʼ19, Editorial Director and Editor, Bates Magazine Johie Seltzer ʼ03, Senior Associate Dean of Admission and Director of Communications and Outreach. 4:05pmNoelle Chaddock, Multicultural Life and Diversity Office, gave a talk at the SUNY Voices System Wide Conference titled “Cultivating Inclusive Campuses Through Intentional Dialogue and Civil Discourse” on March 5 in Albany, N.Y. Also, on Jan. 12, Chaddock presented an opening daylong faculty, staff and senior administration diversity ...Noelle is a 4-Star Geo Claymore character in Genshin Impact. Learn about Noelle's build, ascension materials, best weapons, best artifacts, talent priority, skills, teams, and our rating of the character in this build guide!For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared governance from pointless and unlikely to possible and intriguing, "Shared Governance in Higher Education, Volume 1" will trigger meaningful conversations by offering valuable new perspectives. Experienced governance members, the contributors provide practical insights for everyone involved in academic governance and illuminate the subtle ...February 26 - March 8, 2020 Orpheum Theatre. MARQUEE. ©Disney. February 26 - March 8, 2020. IN MEMORY OF HENRY BRENNER Dear Friend, Welcome to this performance of Disney's Aladdin.Steven D. Parker said that Chaddock’s vision for change inspired him to take the job as assistant dean of the Office of Intercultural Education in August 2020.Meet The Team - Community Education Group. DC . WEST VIRGINIA. (202) 465-1590. [email protected] 9-14, 2018 Orpheum TheatreTop 100 Degree Producers. For several years, Diverse: Issues In Higher Education has produced the Top 100 Degree Producers rankings of the institutions that confer the most degrees to minority students. Using the menu above, you can generate rankings according to the total number of degrees awarded to minority students across all disciplines as well as in specific disciplines.The meeting began with introductions from Hill, Vice President for Equity and Inclusion Noelle Chaddock, and AAC chairs Prof. Amy Douglass, Prof. Nathan Lundblad, Prof. Holly Ewing, and Prof. Susan Starck. Chaddock first set some ground rules before students were given the floor.Sign in Access personal subscriptions, purchases, paired institutional or society access and free tools such as email alerts and saved searches. Book Review: Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality’s Critique of Women’s Studies and the Academy edited by Noelle Chaddock and Beth HinderliterNoelle Chaddock is vice president of equity and inclusion at Bates College. Beth Hinderliter is assistant professor of art history and director of the Duke Hall Gallery of Fine Art at James Madison University.Wellness Wednesday: "Let's Talk About Race: How Race Translates Internationally," led by Chief Diversity Officer Noelle Chaddock and Assistant Director of Multicultural Life and Diversity AnnaMaria Cirrincione, Corey Union Exhibition Lounge, 7 p.m. Thursday, Oct. 22with Noelle Chaddock Paley and Sebastian Purcell. M.O.V.E. Event On April 20, Men of Value and Excellence held a presentation and luncheon with keynote speaker Arel Moodie, one of the leading voices on helping young students get to and get through college. He works with students from all backgrounds to make sure they are ready for the journey ...Rebel Music is an important, one-of-a-kind book that takes readers through fun, radical, educational chapters examining Hip Hop and Punk songs, with each section addressing a particular social issue. Rebel Music values the experiences found in both movements as cultural capital that is de-valued in the current oppressive, standard, test-driven ...Apr 5, 2019 · I haven't published anything in several weeks. I have been writing but have been afraid to publish. This is not because of my ability or inability to write. I do not question the quality or validity of what I am writing. It is because of bullies and self-appointed authenticators in the academic, raced/black and adoption spaces. Graduate school was an ongoing endurance and authentication test ... "Tiana is an outstanding leader and creative problem solver. She demonstrates her talents and skills in her innovative video blog and also through class projects.This reflects a trend at Bates, as well, where not only faculty, but also staff in important roles have been departing at high rates. In July, President Clayton Spencer sent a campus-wide email announcing the departure of Vice President for Equity and Inclusion Dr. Noelle Chaddock, who started at Bates in 2019.Top 100 Degree Producers. For several years, Diverse: Issues In Higher Education has produced the Top 100 Degree Producers rankings of the institutions that confer the most degrees to minority students. Using the menu above, you can generate rankings according to the total number of degrees awarded to minority students across all disciplines as well as in specific disciplines.For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared governance from pointless and unlikely to possible and intriguing, "Shared Governance in Higher Education, Volume 1" will trigger meaningful conversations by offering valuable new perspectives. Experienced governance members, the contributors provide practical insights for everyone involved in academic governance and illuminate the subtle ...This reflects a trend at Bates, as well, where not only faculty, but also staff in important roles have been departing at high rates. In July, President Clayton Spencer sent a campus-wide email announcing the departure of Vice President for Equity and Inclusion Dr. Noelle Chaddock, who started at Bates in 2019.Noelle Chaddock Grounding In: Developing Anti-Racist Facilitation October 22, 2020 3pm – 5pm EST As Vice President for Equity and Inclusion, Noelle Chaddock works with colleagues to cultivate a welcoming, inclusive ...Outstanding Administrator-Noelle Chaddock Jacob Abraham Award-Spencer Beckman Matthew Sean Jones Award-Brittney Threatt Student Organization of the Year-Black Student Association. Student Leadership Honor Council Outstanding Member-Brooks Lamb Social Regulations Council Outstanding Member-Erica Hadley26 dic 2021 ... Noelle Chaddock. Dec 26, 2021. 7 min. I Am Adopted: Hair Grease, Naming and Genealogical Erasure. I was privileged to join a Black Womxn writing ...My dissertation "Mixed Race Identity in the Millennial United States: The Power of Naming our Intimate Realities" spent considerable time contemplating and problematizing the ideas and practices of authenticating socio-racial membership. These ideas of authenticity, and ultimately membership, often lead to monolithic characterizations of what is authentic. There is also a perpetuation of a ...I was privileged to meet with a colleague today who has retired from her institution. This stunning human - a pioneer in women, gender and sexuality studies as well as a huge contributor to race, gender and sexuality discourse - filled up my office and my life just by stepping through the door. She is diminutive in size. She is slight of frame, light of …Noelle Chaddock, PhD. Associate Dean of Academic Affairs for Diversity and Inclusion at Rhodes College. Engaging, genuine and transparently inspiring! Carlos Malave is CJ Motivation-with a truly relatable flair! His, "Translating Your Success" book and workshop is a great addition to any conference seeking to deliver practical tools to ...86 - 91 Beth Hinderliter and Noelle Chaddock, “A Rejection of White Feminist Cisgender Allyship: Centering Intersectionality,” in Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality’s Critique of Women’s Studies and the Academy, Edited by Noelle Chaddock and BethNoelle Chaddock and Beth Hinderliter, eds.: Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality's Critique of Women's Studies and the Academy, Reviewed by Shay Welch; Serene Khader: Decolonizing Universalism: A Transnationalism Feminist Ethic, Reviewed by Jamie Ritzo;View Noelle Chaddock's profile on LinkedIn, the world's largest professional community. Noelle's education is listed on their profile. See the complete profile on LinkedIn and discover ..."Alfred University students produced this exhibit when they observed that a local supermarket's Black history display merely featured boxes of Aunt Jemima Pancake Mix and Uncle Ben's Rice," said Noelle Chaddock Paley, SUNY Cortland's interim director of multicultural life.For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared governance from pointless and unlikely to possible and intriguing, "Shared Governance in Higher Education, Volume 1" will trigger meaningful conversations by offering valuable new perspectives. Experienced governance members, the contributors provide practical insights for everyone involved in academic governance and illuminate the subtle ...Intersectionality works in computational sciences as well!! #intersectionalityNoelle Chaddock is vice president of equity and inclusion at Bates College. Beth Hinderliter is assistant professor of art history and director of the Duke Hall Gallery of Fine Art at James Madison University.Please help Noelle, Ann, and Lyndon welcome them to the team! Ashley Ware, Nicole Holtz and Charee Grover enjoy a break at the Leadership Retreat . The Multicultural Life and Diversity office took 35 students to Adams Eden in Lafayette, NY to develop leadershipNoelle Chaddock, Bates vice president of equity and inclusion, quit last summer. "For me, as a person of color, you have to wonder why is this happening?" Orr asked. "Why are we not having conversations about why this is an uncomfortable place for many folks of color?" Orr asked. "That's not fair to the students.Dr. Noelle Chaddock. Apr 5, 2019; 4 min; Cast Not. 41. 0. 1 like. Post not marked as liked 1. Home: Blog2. About. I am Noelle. That is the only piece of me that has not been radically changed in the last seven days. I am a transracial adoptee born and adopted in 1970-1971. I was born in El Paso, Texas and my parents were stationed on an air ...Noelle Chaddock Paley. The School to Prison Pipeline: From Native America to Urban America . Mecke Nagel, SUNY Cortland . Girls, Suspension, and the School-to-Prison PipelineBook Review: Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality's Critique of Women's Studies and the Academy edited by Noelle Chaddock and Beth Hinderliter. Elizabeth Venell. Gender & Society 0 10.1177/08912432221106766 Download Citation.For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared governance from pointless and unlikely to possible and intriguing, "Shared Governance in Higher Education, Volume 1" will trigger meaningful conversations by offering valuable new perspectives. Experienced governance members, the contributors provide practical insights for everyone involved in academic governance and illuminate the subtle ...Contact & Personal Details. Relatives & Associates. Reviews. Noelle Chaddock is 35 years old today because Noelle's birthday is on 01/01/1988. Noelle calls Canton, OH, home. Noelle maintains relationships with many people -- family, friends, associates, & neighbors -- including Noelle Chaddock, Alexis Chaddock, Matthew Chaddock, Deborah Fields ...Noelle Chaddock, Vice President for Equity and Inclusion Jon Furbush ʼ05, Head Men's Basketball Coach. 3:40pm Audrey Burns ʼ17, Assistant Dean of Admission Jay Burns Pʼ17, Pʼ19, Editorial Director and Editor, Bates Magazine Johie Seltzer ʼ03, Senior Associate Dean of Admission and Director of Communications and Outreach. 4:05pm<p>The language we use matters, especially if we want to enact change upon systemically racist power structures. In today’s episode, we get together with Dr. Noelle Chaddock who received her Ph.D. in philosophy from Binghamton University and serves as the Vice President of Equity and Inclusion at Bates College. She teaches and publishes critical race theory, Black feminism, and Black ...Dr. Noelle Chaddock Don, Laura, Sean, Meredith, Matt, Jon and Sara: Your mother was a light in my and Morgan Celeste's life and we are so deeply saddened by her passing and your pain. We love you all.In fall 2021, Kathleen Plinske, President and CEO of Valencia College, announced a new organizational model to meet the needs of our students and community.Our new model includes the introduction ... View Noelle Chaddock Paley’s profile on LinkedIn, the world’s largest professional community. Noelle has 2 jobs listed on their profile. See the complete profile on LinkedIn …Noelle Chaddock Paley of Endicott, N.Y., was named director of multicultural life and diversity at SUNY Cortland on Dec. 13, a role she has filled on an interim basis since June 2009. Paley, who replaces Don Sawyer III, joined the College in September 2008 as a lecturer in the departments of Africana studies and philosophy.Gordon Bigelow and Noelle Chaddock. 3. Shared Governance: Valuing Each Other and Achieving More Together Belinda S. Miles, Cliff L. Wood, and Kristine Young. Part II: Shared Governance in Times of Change: Necessary Components. 4. Developing Rapport and Relationships with New Administrators Margaret Ann Hoose and Barry Spriggs. 5.Chaddock currently resides in Memphis Tennessee with her daughter Morgan Celeste. Dr. Noelle Chaddock will engage conference attendees in a conversation about the social and individual responsibilities of those doing the work of social justice organizing and advocacy. Chaddock’s recent scholarship and forthcoming book Antagonizing White ... As part of National Public Health Week, Dr. Noelle Chaddock, director of culture and equity , Gordon Bigelow and Noelle Chaddock. 3. Shared Gove, Her books include Antagonizing White Feminism: Intersectionality's Critique of Women's , Bates names Noelle Chaddock as vice president for , For those seeking a way to change opinions of shared govern, I was privileged to join a Black Womxn writing grou, Beth Hinderliter and Noelle Chaddock, SUNY Buffalo and SUNY Cortland. 3. Th, It was my honor and pleasure to serve with Dr. Kimberly Barrett and , 19 jun 2020 ... ... Noelle Chaddock, vice president , For the playwriting readings, a group of 21 actors, including Odle, Noelle Chaddock (editor), Beth Hinderliter (editor), Review published in APA Newsletter on Feminism and Philosophy, Noelle Chaddock is vice president of equity and inclusion, "Go back to where you came from," a man said to Ell, Noelle Chaddock is a Chief Equity and Inclusion Officer at , Beth Hinderliter and Noelle Chaddock, SUNY Buffalo and S, On February 22, Noelle Chaddock Paley presented "The Necessity, Apr 30, 2019 · *a note: I am aware of the antagonism o.